Q: If I could get a home equity loan to pay off my large amount of student loan debt, would this be a good option?
When you’re staring down a large student loan balance, especially high-interest private loans, it’s natural to look for creative solutions. One option many borrowers consider is using a home equity loan to wipe out student debt in one big move. And on the surface, it sounds smart: lower interest rates, one payment, and a fresh start.
But here’s the truth: while a home equity loan can be a strategic financial tool, it can also put your home at risk if the decision isn’t made carefully. This guide breaks down everything you need to know—pros, cons, calculations, risks, alternatives, and real-world examples—to help you make the safest, smartest choice.
CollegeWhale Tip: Before replacing student debt with mortgage debt, slow down and fully evaluate how this decision affects your long-term financial security.
A home equity loan lets you borrow against the value of your home. The amount you can borrow typically depends on:
Lenders usually allow you to borrow up to 75–90% of your home’s value (combined mortgage + home equity loan). Home equity loans have fixed interest rates and act like a second mortgage with predictable monthly payments over 5–30 years.
CollegeWhale Tip: If your credit has improved since you took out your student loans, home equity rates may be significantly lower than your existing loan rates.
Student loan debt—especially private loans—can come with high interest rates and limited repayment flexibility. For homeowners with equity, a home equity loan can seem like a simple shortcut to lower interest and a single monthly payment. But this choice comes with major tradeoffs, which we’ll explore in depth.
Home equity loans often have lower interest rates than student loans—particularly private loans, which commonly range from 8–15%. Home equity loans may fall between 5–9% depending on market conditions and credit history.
CollegeWhale Tip: A difference of just 2–3% interest can save tens of thousands of dollars over a long repayment period.
Most home equity loans come with fixed interest and fixed amortization schedules. This means predictable monthly payments over the entire term—often 10, 15, or 20 years.
For payoff strategies and ways to manage balances over time, take a look at our comprehensive section on Student Loan Debt.
Consolidating multiple student loans into one home equity loan can simplify your finances and potentially reduce your monthly payment.
This strategy can make the most sense for borrowers with high-interest private student loans that offer no forgiveness, no income-based plans, and limited flexibility.
Federal and private student loans are unsecured—meaning no collateral is attached. A home equity loan is secured by your house. If you fall behind, you risk:
CollegeWhale Tip: If job stability or income is uncertain, replacing student loans with mortgage debt can be financially dangerous.
If you use home equity to pay off federal student loans, you lose:
Once you convert your federal loans into mortgage debt, none of these safety nets apply.
A lower monthly payment can feel great now—but it often means paying tens of thousands more in interest over time, especially with a 15–30 year home equity loan.
If you choose a HELOC (line of credit) instead of a fixed home equity loan, your rate can rise dramatically over time.
Profile: Maria, age 32
Maria obtains a 10-year home equity loan for $65,000 at 6.2% APR. Her previous payment was $800/month. Her new payment is $725/month, saving her money monthly AND cutting her interest by nearly half.
CollegeWhale Tip: This works best when you replace high-interest private loans—not federal loans—with stable income and a short repayment term.
Profile: James, age 27
If James used a home equity loan to pay off his student loans:
In this case, a home equity loan would be a serious financial mistake.
If your home equity loan rate is significantly lower than your student loan rates, it may be worth exploring.
A lower monthly payment often means a longer repayment period.
Because your home is collateral, income stability matters more here than with student loans.
If you’re on track for PSLF or another program, using home equity is almost always the wrong move.
You may earn a similar interest rate reduction without putting your home at risk.
Can reduce your payment to as low as $0/month depending on income.
Focus aggressively on high-interest loans first.
Even temporary extra income can make a meaningful dent in student loan debt.
CollegeWhale Tip: Explore every federal option before refinancing or replacing your federal loans with other debt.
Only if the loan is used to improve your home—not to pay off student loans. Most borrowers will not qualify for this deduction.
You can—but variable rates make your payment unpredictable and potentially much higher later.
Yes. Private loans lack forgiveness and income-driven repayment protections, making them the most strategic (and only safe) loans to replace with home equity in some situations.
Using a home equity loan to pay off student loans can be the right move—but only in a narrow set of circumstances. It can lower your rate, simplify your payments, and save money, but it also exposes your home to risk and eliminates federal protections.
If you have strong income, solid home equity, and high-interest private loans, this strategy may pay off. But if you have federal loans or unstable income, it’s usually safer to explore federal repayment options instead.
CollegeWhale Tip: When in doubt, compare every option on paper. A decision this big deserves math, not guesswork.
Fast. Free. No Hidden Promotions. Just Smarter Refinance Insights.
CollegeWhale.com has been a trusted source for college financial aid information for nearly 2 decades! We have been on a mission to connect students (and parents) with free money for college and we haven't stopped yet! Take a look at our Editor Picks for Student Loan Debt
